The 5 best and worst reality tv show judges To celebrate the return of america's got talent on tuesday night, i thought it might be fun to put on our judgment hats and take a few minutes to think about which reality tv show judges out there really rock our socks.And conversely, which ones not so much. So what makes a great reality judge?Is it the ability to make solid judgments about the contestants, complete with the ability to not only advance the shining stars in a given competition, but to add valuable, thoughtful critique to those who get sent home?Is it a knack for entertaining the audience?I mean, i spent half a season of the x factor telling simon cowell to shut up michael kors bags uk from my sofa, but i still relish watching him rip deserving wannabe divas apart.Is it expertise?Flair?An on stage pet, cee lo green style? Actually, it's all of those things okay, maybe not the pet and the wardrobe ... Read more »